I’m very excited about this movie. Patton Oswalt has been promoting the hell out of it (it has literally zero advertising budget), and I generally respect his opinion since I think he’s a good comedian and a smart guy. And how can you not get excited about the directorial debut of Robert Siegel, writer of “The Wrestler” – one of my favorite movies from last year and one of the great trailers of all time.
I was legitimately shocked after viewing this trailer. I hadn’t done a ton of research about the film, but from the bits of interviews with Oswalt I heard here and there – and my own assumptions about the kind of movie he would be in – I had the idea it was going to be somewhat funny. I knew that the writer of “The Wrestler” wasn’t going to throw an all-out comedy out there, but I figured there would be, you know, funny parts.
I was incorrect. There are not. This trailer is downright depressing. Not only that, it actually offended me as a sports fan.
There was a certain realness to “The Wrestler”. It gave a glimpse into the life of what it’s like to be a professional wrestler at a low level. Behind the glamour (which at that low a level was very little), Mickey Rourke’s character lived a painful, lonely life. He suffered through loss, disappointment, and a genuine isolation from society that was believable in that world. And from what I saw in this trailer, Siegel tries to bring those same themes upon the world of fandom. But those themes don’t work in this setting.
Any serious sports fan knows it’s difficult to be isolated when you’re surrounded by thousands of people who want the exact same thing as you. Seeing a sport live is the only setting where I would feel relatively comfortable going alone, since it is one of the easiest places to connect with other people. So Siegel has to fabricate isolation:

This is not remotely close what a tailgate looks like in real life.
The loser-ness of Oswalt’s character is portrayed in cliches: He works as a parking attendant. He scripts his calls to local sports talk radio. He lives at home with his mother. He follows around the star player. There are only so many professions you can look at with a Film Noir perspective, and for me fandom is not one of them. Perhaps Siegel would have been better suited to make a film called “Blogger”, about the tragic isolation of the blogging community: living in their parents basements, pale and overweight, disconnected from society as they spend their days attached to their computers.
I also found the confrontation between Oswalt and the star player a stretch. Sadly, I can’t actually make a serious argument that an NFL player getting involved in an altercation with a fan is farfetched, but Oswalt’s smile when approaching him was so genuine and glowing it was a bit of a shock and quite upsetting to see how it turned out.
The rest of the trailer is dreadful: a crescendo of the dilemma Oswalt faces between his own justice and loyalty to his team, as his relationships with family members seem to spiral out of control. I recommend taking a Zoloft before looking at these:




This shot killed me:

This is PATTON OSWALT we’re talking about! I don’t want him to be “terrific and fearless”, I want him to be “funny” or “hilarious”. It’s such a ridiculous shot that after thinking about it long enough I became genuinely impressed by Oswalt’s acting skills. Could you imagine Dane Cook or Louis C.K. in that shot with that description and not laugh hysterically? I also noticed it looked a tad familiar:

Again, we’re talking about Patton Oswalt here. And I mean no disrespect to him at all – he’s a great comedian and, apparently, and excellent actor. But Mickey Rourke had a unique similarity with his character that made “The Wrestler” into a fantastic movie and gave him an Oscar nomination that he clearly should have won. That trick doesn’t work for Oswalt. I know he’s not a sports fan (from his interviews), but even if I didn’t hear him say it himself, I could have figured it out because this movie makes no sense. Also, I would be willing to bet a semi-large sum of money that Oswalt loses a bet at some point during the movie and has to wear an Eagles jersey as punishment. Oswalt’s character is a Giants fan and hates the Eagles, but we see this at the end of the trailer:

Looks like a Donovan McNabb jersey to me. There’s an extremely brief shot after this that I examined for far too long of Oswalt running in this jersey. It clearly was McSomething but I couldn’t make out the whole name. But just look at the look of disgust on his face and tell me he didn’t just lose a bet with a friend.
I don’t want to come off as a hater of “Big Fan”. But the point that I wanted to emphasize was that I was very surprised by the lack of humor in the trailer. The funniest thing I found out about this movie was that the actor who plays the Giants player who beats up Oswalt is named Jon Hamm. By no means am I saying I don’t think “Big Fan” could still be a great film. Like I said, I am confident that Oswalt and Siegel would not collaborate on something low quality. But I am worried – “The Wrestler” had an amazing trailer and turned out to be an amazing film, I hope the same trend doesn’t follow through for “Big Fan”.
Big Fan is now playing in select theaters.


















